Media Studies - TV
Applying Van Zoonen's viewpoint

EDUQUAS

How might we apply Van Zoonen's viewpoint to No Burqas Behind Bars?


Socialist feminism: Women are restricted and repressed through their domestic roles and utter reliance on the male to provide for them. They have little/no education or power and no way out of poverty – Nadjibeh is forced to sell her son. It is the patriarchal culture which maintains this social inequality.

Radical feminism: Gender roles are reinforced. Men control this society through aggression and the women live in fear of this. Shamsudin as patriarch when patriarchy is challenged (e.g. through the women fleeing) it destroys the women themselves.
Sara says ‘Here you can be yourself. When you are out… They just try to control you’.
The text is written and directed by men so will logically have patriarchal viewpoint, although co-director and producer is female.

Liberal feminism: The representation of women has improved as ideology has changed. Representations reflect our more liberal ideology – we are invited to empathise with the female victims from the privileged perspective of “enlightened” Western culture. Women are not diegetically marginalised but are central to the narrative. The three main protagonists demonstrate strength – Sara’s articulate hope and optimism, Sima’s protection of her son-in-law despite the threat to her own safety, Nadjibeh’s feisty temper.


Show suggestions
Print