Read the following and identify whether the example illustrates a good or weak evaluation. Put them in rank order. Examine how you might improve the answer by identifying any weaknesses it may illustrate. Then click on the text to see if you agree with the comments.

'Finnis’ Natural Law is effective in dealing with ethical issues.'
Evaluate this view.


Now rank each of the two sets of three answers that follow, as to their quality of evaluation. Make your own comments on the answers provided and how the evaluation aspect could be improved. Compare rankings and comments that others in the class have made and assess if there are any significant differences between you.

Question 1

‘Finnis’ Natural Law is a weak theory.’
Evaluate this view.

Arrow
  • Extract 1
  • Extract 2
  • Extract 3
Question 2

An evaluation of Finnis’ Natural Law is a useful guide for contemporary society.
Evaluate this view.

Arrow
  • Extract 1
  • Extract 2
  • Extract 3