PDF Reference
Miracles AO2 handout

Miracles AO2

Read each of the two sets of three answers provided on the accompanying handout. As a group, annotate the handout with your own comments on the answers. Then, use the digital resource to rank the extracts as to their quality of evaluation. Compare rankings and comments that others in the class have made and assess if there are any significant differences between you.

It is unreasonable to believe in miracles. Evaluate this view.

PDF Reference
Miracles AO2 handout

Miracles AO2

Rank each of the two sets of three answers provided on the accompanying handout, as to their quality of evaluation. As a group, make your own comments on the answers provided as a printout. Compare rankings and comments that others in the class have made and assess if there are any significant differences between you.

Question 1

‘Science makes clear that miracles cannot happen.’ Evaluate this view.

Strongest to weakest.
  • T Extract 1
  • T Extract 2
  • T Extract 3

Question 2

‘No testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle.’ Evaluate this view.

Strongest to weakest
  • T Extract 1
  • T Extract 2
  • T Extract 3